What Happened
Darren Woolley, founder and chief executive of marketing consultancy TrinityP3, told attendees at the Mutinex Marketers and Money conference in Melbourne on Tuesday that at least three agencies had reported going through entire pitch processes without any face-to-face contact until the final presentation.
"They'd gone all the way through the process online and by email before they met with the client," Woolley said during a fireside chat at the conference.
He said the pattern came to his attention when agencies began contacting TrinityP3 about pitches the consultancy had no part in. TrinityP3's name had appeared in the documentation. In at least one case, the document included a line at the bottom reading: "Would you like me to prepare a score sheet for this?" — a tell-tale sign the brief had been generated by an AI tool rather than written by a person.
Woolley said Australian advertisers are using AI, including Microsoft Copilot, to write and produce procurement requests. "Having something prepared by Copilot without nuance or customisation has to be a real joke," he said.
His explanation for why marketers are running fully digital processes was blunt: "The only reason you would do that is to save time, and that's the trend that we're seeing emerge amongst marketer-run pitches."
Why It Matters
The shift Woolley described has practical consequences for agencies trying to build genuine client relationships before a pitch decision is made. When the first in-person meeting is the final presentation, agencies have no opportunity to read the room, ask clarifying questions, or tailor their response to the actual people involved.
Woolley framed the trend as the endpoint of a longer cultural shift in the industry. "We've spent two decades engineering the long lunch out of existence, replaced by efficiency metrics, procurement guardrails, back-to-back meetings and ridiculously tight calendars," he said.
The use of AI to generate procurement documents also raises questions about the quality of the briefs agencies are receiving. A Copilot-generated request, Woolley argued, carries none of the contextual knowledge or strategic nuance that a brief written by a senior marketer would contain.
Key Details
Woolley said the agencies involved had, in at least one instance, breached their confidentiality agreements by sharing the documentation with TrinityP3. That breach is how the AI-generated prompt asking about a score sheet came to light.
The Mutinex Marketers and Money conference, where Woolley spoke, was held in Melbourne on Tuesday, 18 November 2026. His comments were reported by Mumbrella's Eleanor Dickinson.
The trend Woolley identified is specific to marketer-run pitches, as distinct from pitches managed by an independent consultant. He did not name the advertisers involved.
Background and Context
TrinityP3 is an Australian marketing management consultancy that advises both advertisers and agencies on pitch processes, remuneration, and agency rosters. Woolley has been a consistent voice in the Australian marketing industry on the mechanics of agency selection.
The broader context is a decade-long squeeze on the time and resources allocated to agency pitches. Procurement departments have taken a larger role in managing agency selection, and digital communication tools have made it easier to run processes without scheduling in-person meetings.
AI tools capable of drafting procurement documents are now widely available to marketing teams. Microsoft Copilot, which Woolley named, is integrated into the Microsoft 365 suite used by many large Australian organisations.
What Comes Next
Woolley's prescription for agencies facing this environment was direct. "You're going to have to revert back to new business strategy of the 1980s, where you just go out and knock on doors and schmooze people and try to get in," he said.
Whether advertisers running AI-assisted pitches will adjust their processes in response to industry criticism remains to be seen. No response from any advertiser or procurement body was reported at the time of publication.